I Swear I Didn't Write These Reviews! Icelandic Flake Sea Salt

Posted on September 12, 2017 by Scott Eirinberg

About a year ago, I started asking our customers to write reviews about the products that they bought from us. I figured it might be a good idea to let people know what others thought about our stuff rather than just blabbing about it myself.

Sure, I expected people to be satisfied and say nice things. After all, we are incredibly picky about the quality of the products that we sell. We are proud to supply some of the top restaurant chefs from around the country. But the thing is, you never really know what people are going to say when you give them the opportunity.

Please believe me when I tell you that I SWEAR I DIDN'T WRITE ANY OF THESE REVIEWS! (And no, neither did any of my friends or family. Though some of these customers have become my friends since writing these reviews!)

At the time of this post, we had 20 reviews of our Icelandic Sea Salt. 95% of the reviews gave them 5-Stars.

Not bad! Our Icelandic Sea Salt has received over 95% 5-Star Reviews. And I swear I didn't write any of them!

Here are just a few of the reviews.

6 stars out of 5! There are two things that always need to happen together when merchandizing a product. They are: presentation and superior product. The Reluctant Trading Experiment hit the nail on the head, not only with the salt but also with the pepper. I will be back and also trying more products. Keep on knocking the ball out of the ball park! I would give them 6 stars out of 5!

postcard from Iceland I don't get out often enough, out meaning the hinterlands of my travel dreams + desires, so crafting chocolate is my magic carpet so to speak. I was in search for the perfect addition to a special bar I had in mind, and this salt beckoned. Can a salt taste of thermal pools and fjords and the bright sting of winter on your face? yes. oh my yes. Wonderfully crumbly, lovely layered flavors.

Super fast service I procrastinated getting my very best girlfriend something for her birthday. I slipped in just under the wire and purchased some pepper and salt for her on Friday. Her birthday was Monday. It got there for her birthday! Wow! How good of service was that. Still don't know what she thought of the product yet. I got a thank you, but I haven't tried it yet from her. (We live states away from each other.) I can't wait to hear how she liked the pepper. I haven't tried it yet. I'm in love with the salt. Anyway, don't do like I did and wait till the last minute. But if ya do, you might get away with it. Thanks!

Salt of the earth – The Icelandic men who harvest our sea salt.

Great products and interestingly presented. Flavorful products and presented differently, great for gifting, except when you see them you'll want for yourself. The grinders work perfectly.the entire experience with this company has been Top Notch. I would highly recommend them to anyone.

Best- bar none! As a restaurant professional, classically trained chef and just all around food geek, there is no better place to get spices this fresh without hopping on a plane and traveling half way around the world. The Icelandic Flake sea salt is that perfect way to finish a dish to make those flavors pop. Try it on some seared Sea Scallops, you'll thank Scott over and over again!

We enjoy it more than we expected We love the salt and pepper in the flask so much, much more than expected. all my friends are tired of hearing about it. It's our new favorite gift to give. And we are making food specifically to cover in pepper and salt. Like corn on the cob and pasta. Just to taste the pepper. And that is only because we should not eat just pepper and salt.

The Great Salt debate of 2017 I really love the intensity of this salt. a very "briny" aspect that is delightful. After some adjustments I can verify that the salt will work with the grinder as well. The whole process was smooth, as usual. This company truly expresses a personal interest in their customers that is woefully lacking today in so many others. Repeat customer(offender), feeding a salt and pepper "monkey on my back" like Yoda teaching Luke.

Our Icelandic Sea Salt comes from some of the cleanest water on earth.

The Best Salt I have about 15 different types of salt in my cupboard, 4 of them flake salts. Icelandic flake salt is my go to for meats and I recently had to buy extra to give some to my sister because she loved it so much. We had a family gathering and she asked me to bring the Icelandic flake salt because it was so good. Unfortunately I was out, so I brought some Hawaiian flake salt and after the meal she asked me to order her up the Icelandic salt because it was so much better then what I brought. I can not recommend this salt enough, it is the perfect salt. Great company to buy from with fast shipping.


Shop our Icelandic Sea Salt in a variety of sizes.

Icelandic Coarse Flake Sea Salt - America's Best Kept Secret

Posted on April 23, 2015 by Scott Eirinberg

It's been a couple of years since I discovered our coarse, flaky Sea Salt being hand-harvested by a small team off the coast of Iceland. I still have fond memories of that trip. Gorgeous country, wonderful people.

Last year at dinner, it hit me again. This is the best damn salt in America. Even if it is still a best kept secret.

I've been eating this stuff daily for a couple of years now. And it really is all that. During this time, I could have added several different salts that cost a lot less (importing from Iceland is pricey) allowing Reluctant to make bigger margins. But that's not what Reluctant is all about. My 13 year-old son makes a mean homemade pizza. Icelandic sea salt elevates it to an otherworldly place.

I really believe in this flaky Icelandic Salt. And the customers who have tried it just keep coming back for more. So it's not just me. It doesn't surprise me that a lot of top chefs in Copenhagen use it in their kitchens. But let's talk about our kitchen for a minute.

Last night, my youngest son made homemade pizza. I'm talking gourmet stuff. San Gimignano tomatoes, homemade crust, prosciutto, arugula.

Anyway, my son sprinkles a little Icelandic on the pizza after it comes out of the oven.

Let's just say that if you would have analyzed my tears of joy, you would have likely found that they contained Icelandic salt. I use the stuff a lot.

The salt workers of Iceland. These guys know what they're doing.

There's something about this magical salt that brings out the best in everything it touches. The saltiness, the coarseness, the crunch, the flakes. A little pinch can bring out so many flavors. As my son likes to say, "Just wow."

Pizza, salmon, tomato sauces, dark chocolate. You'll find those things that just work with it and make one plus one equal three.

Sorry to blab on like this. It just hit me again last night and I had to tell you what I was feeling. 

Hey look, if you buy some and don't like it, I'll give you your money back. Really.

You can buy the Icelandic coarse, flaky sea salt here.

This is where I went to get the sea salt in Iceland. Easy on the eyes and the taste buds.


You can buy the Icelandic coarse, flaky sea salt here.

Headed to Iceland for Artisanal Sea Salt on May 28

Posted on May 16, 2013 by Scott Eirinberg

On May 28, I’ll be headed to Iceland to bring back flake sea salt from the Norwegian Sea. I’ll be arriving in Reykjavik, the capital. My friend Bjorn will pick me up and we’ll drive 4 hours north to his salt making facility in the Westfjords. For two days, Bjorn and company will teach me how to hand-harvest their pure, artisanal sea salt. I’ll be sharing all of the details as they happen on this blog, Facebook and Twitter. So be sure to follow along. Time Magazine recently named the Westfjords one of the world’s 24 best kept secrets. But I’m afraid I’m just going to have to spill the beans. 

The Icelandic Flaky Sea Salt is now available.

Reluctant Trading Icelandic Flaky Sea Salt


Like this post? Sign up for The Reluctant Trading Newsletter to keep up with the latest.

Scroll to top